Hello
If I lose my internet connection or I have a problem with my netbox, my OCO order will be lost if I did not choose a broker that hosts itself this type of order.
On this page (https://www.multicharts.com/brokers/), I see there is only one broker which propose an OCO order tracked by itself (IB).
Can you confirm that there is only IB which offer to host this type of order?
best regards
Broker and OCO order
- JoshM
- Posts: 2195
- Joined: 20 May 2011
- Location: The Netherlands
- Has thanked: 1544 times
- Been thanked: 1565 times
- Contact:
Re: Broker and OCO order
While waiting for confirmation, this is what I found on the wiki:
Source: Trading risks - OCO orders.Native OCO-group is used when the broker’s API supports OCO-groups. In this case all OCO orders are sent to the broker directly and unfilled OCO orders will be cancelled by the broker. (Native OCO-group is supported by Interactive Brokers, FXCM and IWBank).
Re: Broker and OCO order
For clarification, your OCO order is not lost, both orders are waiting for execution. What happens is when one fills, the broker relies on MC to tell it to cancel the remaining open order. Still a legitimate concern. Why I have power back ups on my machine and router even why my systems usually trade less than 40 minutes a day, often far less than that.
Re: Broker and OCO order
What ??? The thread opener is saying that he can't see his OCO's after he lost connection and you want to tell that it sits somewhere while he can not see his 'old' OCO after he has connection to the broker back up again ?For clarification, your OCO order is not lost, both orders are waiting for execution. What happens is when one fills, the broker relies on MC to tell it to cancel the remaining open order. Still a legitimate concern. Why I have power back ups on my machine and router even why my systems usually trade less than 40 minutes a day, often far less than that.
From my understanding, an OCO order sent to a broker supporting OCO order hosting on their system should stay their till further instruction is given whether the connection is lost or not. If the connection was lost and the order can't be seen again, it is a sync problem between broker & MC. If an OCO order is given locally only, while the broker doesn't support hosting OCO's, it should still stay locally after the connection is back up again.
Re: Broker and OCO order
That's so kind of you to ridicule someone whose answer you do not feel is correct. Thanks!What ??? The thread opener is saying that he can't see his OCO's after he lost connection and you want to tell that it sits somewhere while he can not see his 'old' OCO after he has connection to the broker back up again ?For clarification, your OCO order is not lost, both orders are waiting for execution. What happens is when one fills, the broker relies on MC to tell it to cancel the remaining open order. Still a legitimate concern. Why I have power back ups on my machine and router even why my systems usually trade less than 40 minutes a day, often far less than that.
From my understanding, an OCO order sent to a broker supporting OCO order hosting on their system should stay their till further instruction is given whether the connection is lost or not. If the connection was lost and the order can't be seen again, it is a sync problem between broker & MC. If an OCO order is given locally only, while the broker doesn't support hosting OCO's, it should still stay locally after the connection is back up again.
Re: Broker and OCO order
Some time ago the AMP website said that the Multicharts.Net Special Edition is with server side OCO. So I asked if this is also true for the normal version.
Here what AMP answered me not long ago....
CQG data feed does offer server side OCO with Multi-charts easy language. Here is a link to request for demo credentials.
http://www.ampfutures.com/platforms/mul ... -language/
Johnny...
From:......
Sent: Monday, February 01, 2016 10:00 AM
To: AMP - LA - Johnny Khek
Subject: Aw: AMP Support
Johnny,
Is MULTICHARTS 9.1 with EasyLanguage with server side OCO, too?
Thanks and best regards
.....
Here what AMP answered me not long ago....
CQG data feed does offer server side OCO with Multi-charts easy language. Here is a link to request for demo credentials.
http://www.ampfutures.com/platforms/mul ... -language/
Johnny...
From:......
Sent: Monday, February 01, 2016 10:00 AM
To: AMP - LA - Johnny Khek
Subject: Aw: AMP Support
Johnny,
Is MULTICHARTS 9.1 with EasyLanguage with server side OCO, too?
Thanks and best regards
.....
- Henry MultiСharts
- Posts: 9165
- Joined: 25 Aug 2011
- Has thanked: 1264 times
- Been thanked: 2958 times
Re: Broker and OCO order
That is correct. CQG connection has native (server side) OCO group support since switching to the Web API in version 9.1. The corresponding web pages have been updated.Some time ago the AMP website said that the Multicharts.Net Special Edition is with server side OCO. So I asked if this is also true for the normal version.
Here what AMP answered me not long ago....
CQG data feed does offer server side OCO with Multi-charts easy language.
Re: Broker and OCO order
Hello,That is correct. CQG connection has native (server side) OCO group support since switching to the Web API in version 9.1. The corresponding web pages have been updated.Some time ago the AMP website said that the Multicharts.Net Special Edition is with server side OCO. So I asked if this is also true for the normal version.
Here what AMP answered me not long ago....
CQG data feed does offer server side OCO with Multi-charts easy language.
This is true although I have an account through AMP?
On pages about brokers is it specified native orders for CQG but for AMP are not native orders.
- Henry MultiСharts
- Posts: 9165
- Joined: 25 Aug 2011
- Has thanked: 1264 times
- Been thanked: 2958 times
Re: Broker and OCO order
This is also true for AMP accounts that work through CQG connection. As you can see AMP supports multiple different infrastructures, so you need to refer to the one you are going to use.Hello,That is correct. CQG connection has native (server side) OCO group support since switching to the Web API in version 9.1. The corresponding web pages have been updated.Some time ago the AMP website said that the Multicharts.Net Special Edition is with server side OCO. So I asked if this is also true for the normal version.
Here what AMP answered me not long ago....
CQG data feed does offer server side OCO with Multi-charts easy language.
This is true although I have an account through AMP?
On pages about brokers is it specified native orders for CQG but for AMP are not native orders.