I've tried this mode for stop orders
"Emulate locally using Trade and send a Market order"
but it is not works.
After price riched a stop order at the chart window its turn to the trade, but at the order list appears the line with cancellation of it.
Finally we have an open position at Multicharts window, but, no any at the account.
Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
-
- Posts: 43
- Joined: 27 Oct 2019
- Has thanked: 29 times
- Been thanked: 1 time
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
Cancelling the stop, then sending a market order in its place, should be the behaviour you’re observing, once a trade triggers you synthetic stop.
Is this not happening??
I have no issues using this feature my end.
Is this not happening??
I have no issues using this feature my end.
-
- Posts: 43
- Joined: 27 Oct 2019
- Has thanked: 29 times
- Been thanked: 1 time
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
Usually i have this record at Orders List: this picture from MC 12Cancelling the stop, then sending a market order in its place, should be the behaviour you’re observing, once a trade triggers you synthetic stop.
Is this not happening??
I have no issues using this feature my end.
At MC 14 I also have cancelled stop order and no any market orders sending
Also i use Async Mode, maybe have matter. But, as I know it is not possible to work with Emulation in Sync mode
-
- Posts: 43
- Joined: 27 Oct 2019
- Has thanked: 29 times
- Been thanked: 1 time
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
Working with the following presetsSo you are saying that this issue is unique to MC14? I have no experience of live MC14.
MC12 async order emulation works fine.
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
I had this issue with MC14 when using Binance. I was told emulation using trade price doesn't work atm. I haven't tried it with other brokers to confirm whether its unique to Binance. Using MC12 i use this all the time and it works well.
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
I can confirm these settings work, in both charts and portfolio trader. Although if you manually move the orders for whatever reason, orders wont trigger, so clearly a bug.Working with the following presetsSo you are saying that this issue is unique to MC14? I have no experience of live MC14.
MC12 async order emulation works fine.
2021-01-30_16-39-26.jpg
- Kate MultiCharts
- Posts: 614
- Joined: 21 Oct 2020
- Has thanked: 12 times
- Been thanked: 155 times
Re: Problems with Emulation trading mode at MC 14
Hello andreinvest,
If a broker does not provide Trade data, then the emulation will not work.
On the screenshot you provided we can see that your data provider is EasyTrade. We do not have any info about the amount and types of data provided by this vendor, you can contact them directly to find out.
We can recommend using Ask and Bid for emulation instead of Trade.
Alternatively, you can try opening Strategy Properties -> Auto Trading tab -> in the Get Real-Time Data section select Chart. In that case the emulator will work, since it will be taking into account chart prices.
If a broker does not provide Trade data, then the emulation will not work.
On the screenshot you provided we can see that your data provider is EasyTrade. We do not have any info about the amount and types of data provided by this vendor, you can contact them directly to find out.
We can recommend using Ask and Bid for emulation instead of Trade.
Alternatively, you can try opening Strategy Properties -> Auto Trading tab -> in the Get Real-Time Data section select Chart. In that case the emulator will work, since it will be taking into account chart prices.